Short answer
- Historic Environment Scotland advises checking with the planning authority before making repairs to a listed building.
- Like-for-like repair may not need listed building consent if it does not affect character, but material, detail or appearance changes can require consent.
- A roof survey should record existing slate, leadwork, chimneys, gutters, lime mortar and proposed repair details before work is specified.
The short answer
You may not need listed building consent for straightforward like-for-like roof repair that does not affect the building's character, but you should check with the planning authority before starting.
Consent questions become more likely when the work changes materials, roof profile, visible details, structural fabric or the appearance of a listed building.
What like-for-like roof repair means
Like-for-like does not simply mean using a similar colour. On a historic roof, size, thickness, texture, fixing method, lead detailing, lime mortar and visible roof pattern can all matter.
If replacement slate, modern substitutes, altered flashings, cement mortar or changed roofline details are proposed, the safest route is to get council advice before work begins.
Listed buildings and conservation areas
Listed building consent is handled by the planning authority in Scotland. Conservation areas are also local authority matters, and even unlisted buildings can sit in sensitive streets where roof appearance is important.
The roofing inspection should therefore record the building status, location, roof visibility, proposed materials and whether any emergency temporary work has already been carried out.
Emergency leaks on listed buildings
Urgent weatherproofing may be needed to protect the building fabric, but emergency work should still be documented carefully. Take photos, keep notes and avoid unnecessary removal of historic material.
Once the leak is stable, the permanent repair should be specified with conservation sensitivity and any consent checks completed before visible changes are made.
What to prepare before asking for advice
Gather the address, listed status if known, safe photos of the roof, photos of internal damage, details of previous repairs and any correspondence from the council or property factor.
For shared buildings such as tenements, churches or public buildings, also record access constraints, ownership arrangements and whether scaffold or neighbouring access may be needed.
Useful Scottish references
- Historic Environment Scotland: listed building consent Scottish guidance on listed building consent, like-for-like repair and planning authority checks.
- Historic Environment Scotland: living in a listed building Owner guidance on permission, suitable materials and conservation-experienced trades.
- Scottish Government: conservation areas Guidance on conservation areas, listed building consent and local planning authority advice.
- mygov.scot: building warrants Scottish homeowner guidance on when building plans may need a building warrant.
- Historic Environment Scotland: maintenance of traditional buildings Scottish maintenance guidance covering water ingress, roof coverings, gutters, chimneys and inspection tips.
